UPSC Mains 2025 GS Paper 2 Question Paper
Q. E-governance projects have a built-in bias towards technology and back-end integration than user-centric designs. Examine.
Introduction:
E-governance in India has largely been driven by technology-led, backend integration approaches, often at the cost of user-centric service delivery and accessibility.
- Meaning of the Statement
- Focus on:
- Digitization of processes (automation, databases)
- Inter-departmental integration
- Neglect of:
- User experience (UX)
- Accessibility, inclusiveness
- Evidence of Technology Bias
(a) Backend-heavy Architecture
- Emphasis on data integration, portals, dashboards
- Success measured by number of services digitized, not outcomes
Example:
- Early e-Seva portals → complex navigation, low usability
(b) One-size-fits-all Design
- Ignoring regional, linguistic, literacy differences
- Limited localization
(c) Digital Divide
- Rural/elderly/poor face barriers:
- Internet access
- Digital literacy
Data:
- Internet penetration ~50–55% in India (varies regionally)
(d) Process-centric, not citizen-centric
- Replication of bureaucratic procedures online
- No simplification of rules
- Causes of Bias
- Tech-driven policy approach (IT-centric ministries)
- Vendor-driven implementation
- Lack of user research & feedback loops
- Capacity gaps in administration
- Implications
- Exclusion of vulnerable groups
- Low adoption rates of services
- Persistence of middlemen / offline dependency
- Reduced trust in digital governance
- Improvements & Positive Trends
(a) Shift towards User-centric Governance
- NITI Aayog → emphasis on Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI)
- Mobile-first governance
(b) Successful Models
- Aadhaar-enabled DBT → ease of access
- UPI → simple, interoperable payments
- UMANG app → single interface for services
(c) Policy Initiatives
- Digital India Programme
- Open APIs, India Stack → modular approach
- Critical Evaluation
- Initial phase → technology-centric
- Emerging phase → gradual shift to citizen-centric design
- Yet, gap persists in last-mile delivery
- Way Forward
- Adopt “citizen-first design thinking”
- Conduct user testing, feedback loops
- Ensure multilingual, inclusive interfaces
- Strengthen digital literacy & assisted access (CSC centres)
- Simplify business processes before digitization
- Ensure data privacy & trust
Conclusion:
Bridging the gap between technological capability and citizen needs through inclusive, user-centric design is essential for realizing the true potential of e-governance in India
UPSC MAINS GS II Question Paper with Explanation PDF Download here